My slight Ponyis one of those kid - friendly franchises that has get by to appeal to hoi polloi of all ages . Whether you became a fan as a small fry back in the eighties or discovered it recently by follow one of the newer film orTV showswith your minor , there ’s no denying its enduring charm .

It all began in 1981 thanks to Bonnie Zacherle , who grew up wanting a pony of her own . She set about out working on salutation plug-in , then did freelance purpose study forHasbrobefore bring together the fellowship full time in the early eighties . Once in - house , she focused on toy dog ideas that were similar to “ what I would have work with as a minor , ” she say in a2016 consultation .

From her puerility love of ponies , My Pretty Pony — which would finally becomeMy Little Pony — was give birth . After several iterations and overcoming Hasbro ’s initial ohmic resistance , the classic plaything ponies we all make out and beloved were release to the multitude by 1982 , cause the famous brand millions over the years .

1987 My Little Pony So Soft & Twinkle-Eyed Ponies Commercial | Hasbro

While the original toys thatXennialsplayed with likely wo n’t net you zillion , they are deserving a nice chunk of alteration now . you may carry a few hundred dollars or more , based in part upon the calibre and oddity of yourFirst Generation ( G1)My Little Pony toys . Below are some of the most valuable piece from the ’ 80s and early ’ 90s that you’re able to resell on eBay .

Table of Contents

Mimic Twinkle-Eyed My Little Pony, G1 Year 5 (1987) // Up to $2000

Her limited production and unparalleled appearing have givenMimic , one of theTwinkle - Eyed G1   pony , a extra situation in the hearts of many My Little Pony collector . She come out in a time of year two instalment called “ Golden shoe . ” While she did n’t say much — in fact , only three linesif you ’re counting — she come across with fans everywhere . Part of what made her so special were her beady eyes and her parrot “ cutie fool , ” which is asymbolunique to each pony fiber located on the toy dog ’s hindquarters .

Fans theorizethat Hasbro did a limited product on the plaything because of her calx - green coloring , as they were n’t sure it would appeal to girls .   A Mimic pony still in its promotion recently sell for nearly $ 2000 on eBay — but even if you have one you ’ve played with before , you could still clear between $ 250 and $ 300 for parting with it .

Rapunzel My Little Pony, G1 Year 9 (1990) // Up to $1500

Imagine calling out for Rapunzel to throw down her locks and you get a pony ’s voluptuary head of hair alternatively ? That may be a dream descend dependable . During the ’ 90s post - parliamentary law era of Hasbro toys , theRapunzel My Little Ponybecame one of therarest findsof them all .

With her long strawberry blonde coif and distinctive tush ( which sports a princess - themed cutie mark ) , this miniature became very coveted among collectors . One foot is dead set back as if she ’s mid - trot , too ( this is know as the “ Love Melody ” impersonate ) . If you happen to have one now , you could sell it for a bundle . Potentially around $ 1000 to $ 1500 , to be precise .

My Little Pony Mommy and Baby Pony, G1 Year 9 (1990) // Up to $776

Another blue runner - up in the most valuable G1 My Little Pony contest is theMommyandBaby Ponycombo Seth . It hail with a babe feeding bottle and pen , so mommy can have a little “ me ” fourth dimension ( or at least catch up on stuff around the menage ) . The Mommy also has an endearing cutie score of a animated cartoon kitty and her child on the rump . Meanwhile , the Baby has a diaper - esque stamp on hers .

With the complete set and accessories , you could potentially receive up to $ 776 on eBay . Even without the accessories , pre - owned versions of this G1 jazz band could gain up to $ 280 .

My Little Pony Paradise Estate, G1 Year 4 (1985) // Up to $700

Every pony needs a billet to call their own , and the My footling Pony Paradise Estate fork out in every room . Although a jigger was not included with this swordplay bent , there was mickle to bask about it otherwise , include draw of toy furniture , an outside patio with a fillable puddle for cooling off and making neighbors envious , and a bedroom to chill out in during off hours . On the original packaging , there was even a backstory aboutShady the Ponylosing her magic sunglasses during a gathering and involve assistance to retrieve them .

Have one of your own that you want to part with ? A brand - new version still inside the box can go for as much as $ 700 on eBay . In pre - loved condition , you may get up to $ 450 for this one . sure accessories can potentially be deserving up to about $ 50 .

My Little Pony Dream Castle Play Set, G1 Year 2 and Year 7 (1983, 1989) // Up to $450

Paradise Estate was n’t the only play set kids could bask back in the day . This peculiar castle was feature inRescue at Midnight Castle , a 1984 animated My Little Pony TV special , which is part of why it was so popular with lover .

Thefirst versionfrom Year 2 , circa1983 , was a pinkish palace and it came withMajestyand her pet flying lizard , Spike . There are also legion accessories to raise the castle experience further . The 1989 edition , released as part of theYear 7 stock , is often referred to as the Lavender Dream Castle and is a bit rarer . A complete but used reading of the lavender one recently earned $ 450 on eBay . Even the box alone is worth about $ 90 . The original pinkish translation is worth a bite less , but you may still get up to about $ 200 for it .

My Little Pony Waterfall Set With Sprinkles, G1 Year 2 (1983) // Up to about $400

Who does n’t wish to decompress under a waterfall during their downtime ? This Year 2 fun set feature a little swarm , rainbow , and sun also gives shot glass a terrific shoes to bath . It came withSprinkles , a plaything pegasus with a pencil eraser duck buddy , plus a sponge brush and cockscomb , curlers , a towel , and house of cards bath solution . Once hooked up , there was a working petty pool and shower you could utilise with the accessory .

If you have a complete set in good condition , you could collect about $ 200 or more . Or for those who happen to have the rare mail service - order Sprinkles pony include , you might profit about $ 400 .

My Little Pony Sweet Scoops Pony, G1 Year 8 (1990) // Up to $350

While not all mail - decree ponies have important resale value , Sweet Scoopsranks up there . She was secrete in the other ’ ninety with a matching charm necklace that fans could show off to their other pony - loving friends . As her name connote , she has an ice cream scoop cutie cross , showing off her love for her favorite afters .

If you have just the crib and she ’s in expert condition , you could receive up to $ 350 on eBay , while the charm on her necklace alone is deserving as much as $ 100 on the internet site . If you happen to have both , it ’s hard to say on the dot how much you ’ll reach , but it’sone of the rarer finds . For those who have the set in good condition , it could fetch you a pretty penny .

My Pretty Pony (1981) // Up to $300

Before My Little Pony became what it is today , it started as My Pretty Pony . That did n’t quite get off the ground like Hasbro and Zacherle thought it would , hence the release ofunique - colored ponieswith specific identities to invoke to a wide hearing . But that does n’t intend you ca n’t still reap the rewards of being a fan of the pilot , which was about 10 inches improbable — much adult than next versions , which were generally 5 in tall .

You might think the original rendering is the most valuable My Little Pony plaything in the gang , but shockingly , it ’s not . A used Romper Room pink trot that still had its box lately blend in for around $ 300 on eBay . Versions in brownish only garner previous owners about $ 100 or so .

My Little Pony Soft Sleepy Newborns, G1 Year 5 (1987) // Up to $200

It goes without enunciate that newborn anything is adorable ( except for spiders , they do n’t count ) . Thenewbornsin the My Little Pony G1 personal line of credit are no exception . They were an strange 9 inches magniloquent , so they were standardized in sizing to My Pretty Pony but significantly big than the usual My Little Pony toys . Their middle opened and closed when you tilt them or pulled their tails , and they were made of a piano cloth . You even have a pacifier with each one ( aw ! ) .

Three model werereleasedduring Year 5 : Pink Dreams , Hushabye , and Sweet Dreams . All of them loosely have roughly the same resale value on eBay . If you are ready to part with your newborn My Little Pony , you could earn between $ 100 and $ 200 on eBay .

understand More About Valuable Collectibles :

Most valuable My Little Pony toys: G1 Mimic Twinkle-Eyed My Little Pony is pictured.

Most valuable My Little Pony toys: G1 Rapunzel My Little Pony pictured.

Most valuable My Little Pony toys: G1 Mommy and Baby Pony are pictured.

Most valuable My Little Pony toys: G1 Dream Castle Play set

Most valuable My Little Pony toys: Waterfall set with Sprinkles

Most valuable My Little Pony toys: Sweet Scoops G1 My Little Pony

Most valuable My Little Pony toys: My Pretty Pony is seen.

Most Valuable My Little Pony toys: Hushabye Soft Sleepy Newborn toy pictured.