David Trimble and Madison Myers’ cataclysmic affair rocked the cast ofMarried At First Sightseason 18,but was their relationship built to last? David and Madison first forged a bond during gym sessions on their Mexican honeymoon. Their budding romance had one problem – they were both married to other people. The relationship experts had paired David with Michelle Tomblin, while Madison was matched with Allen Slovick.
Despite the experts’ best intentions, neither couple seemed to be on the path to success.While Allen was head-over-heels for Madison, she never shared the same affection for him. Meanwhile, David and Michelle never managed to form a connection, with Michelle struggling to accept many of David’s habits and living situation. A breaking point emerged whenMichelle caught David in a sexting scandal, and her intuition told her the intended recipient was Madison. When the truth was revealed, it ended both relationships and marked the beginning of a new one.
David And Madison’s MAFS Journey
Their Secret Attraction Began Early In Season 18
Details are murky about whenDavid and Madison’s relationshipstarted, but the couple became gym buddies shortly after marrying their respective partners.They started working out together on the group honeymoon and continued after they returned home to Chicago, using their gym sessions to vent and offer support about their marital problems. David appeared uncharacteristically chipper after their sessions together, a noticeable change in his demeanor from his interactions with his wife.
20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
David and Madison also enjoyed nights out in group settings, contributing to Michelle’s rising suspicions about their relationship. While David was out with Madison and Allen, Michelle received a text from him that read,“You are so damn fine I just wanna eat U up.”Considering the bleak status of their marriage, she was sure the text was intended for somebody else, concluding the text was David’s way of flirting with Madison right under Allen’s nose.
When David and Madison’s mutual attraction was revealed during the couples’ retreat, each denied having acted on their feelings before.However, their detachment from their spouses and Madison’s history of staying out until the early morning hours cast doubt on their denial. Dr. Pia Holec even outright accused the couple of lying about not having been intimate. Nevertheless, David and Madison claimed to be taking their relationship slow and were beginning to date at the end ofMarried At First Sightseason 18.
Are David And Madison Still Together?
They Were Seen On An Apparent Date In Late 2024
Although David and Madison’s relationship status is unconfirmed, the internet is abuzz with rumors about their romance.Instagram accountMAFS Fan, which has over 90K followers, alleges David and Madison are either engaged or married. While social media speculation should be taken with a grain of salt,MAFS Fanalso accurately predicted David and Madison’s involvement in the couple swap and thatCamille Parsons and Thomas McDonaldwould be the only season 18 couple to remain married, which gives their claims some credence.
Even if they aren’t engaged, it seems David and Madison’s relationship is still going strong.
David and Madison have also been spotted out together in public, withMAFS Fansharing photos of the couple, dated June 10, 2025.The pictures show David sitting next to a blonde woman in a black striped coat, while another photo clearly shows Madison wearing the same coat in what appears to be the same location.Even if they aren’t engaged, it seems David and Madison’s relationship is still going strong.
Our Take On David & Madison’s Relationship
They Both Have A History Of Disloyalty
While David and Madison did meet their goal of finding a partner throughMarried At First Sight, the way they went about their relationship raises concerns about their future together. As Pastor Cal Roberson pointed out, when inappropriate feelings emerged, David and Madison should have first taken their concerns to their respective spouses. Their willingness to allow their shared attraction to flourish outside their existing marriages proves a lack of loyalty and boundaries that could spell trouble in David and Madison’s future.
David and Madison were too eager to give up on their marriages to Michelle and Allen, which suggests their relationship may not have much longevity. However,Married At First Sightseason 18 was filmed in 2023, meaning that if David and Madison are still together in 2025, they may be in it for the long haul. Although they didn’t follow the conventional method of finding a partner, if David and Madison are happy together, then we wish them the best.
Married At First Sightairs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. EST on Lifetime.
